New paper “The structural fragmentation of energy poverty metrics limits global comparability and policy targeting”

Energy poverty describes a condition in which households cannot afford or access essential energy services such as heating, cooling, lighting, and power. Its measurement has evolved from affordability-based indicators to complex multidimensional frameworks, but this diversification has produced a fragmented measurement landscape. Building on a previous systematic literature review, we compared the structure of 25 widely used energy poverty indices.

Our analysis reveals that:

  • Most metrics capture less than 35% of the identified dimensional space.
  • Around 96% rely on only one or two methodological approaches.
  • Approximately 92% were developed within specific national or subnational contexts.
  • Climate, thermal comfort and environmental vulnerability remain comparatively underrepresented.

These patterns reveal a structurally fragmented system dominated by a narrow set of economic and technical dimensions, with limited incorporation of contextual and structural drivers.

Most indices focus on a narrow set of economic and technical dimensions such as access, expenditure, energy consumption, and income. Only two indices reach the maximum dimensional coverage of 55.6%, and only one integrates three methodological approaches. Most pairwise Jaccard coefficients remain below 0.50, so indices rarely combine the same dimensions even when they address similar phenomena. High similarity occurs only among indices that share the same methodological logic, mainly affordability-based ones. Combined with strong reliance on local thresholds and benchmarks, this limits comparability across climatic, territorial, and policy contexts.

Two structurally different indices applied to the same population can identify different households as energy poor. Choosing an index is therefore not a neutral technical decision, because it shapes who receives policy support and resources.

Our network analysis shows that measurement outcomes result from the interaction between variables, methodological approaches, and analytical scale rather than from individual dimensions. We therefore reframe energy poverty metrics as integrated evaluation frameworks and propose a three-layer structure that distinguishes core outcome, determinant, and structural vulnerability dimensions. This structure enables comparability at the dimensional level. Different settings can share a common organization while using locally available variables, which avoids transferring data-intensive formulations between contexts. Qualitative or participatory evidence can complement subjective and context-specific dimensions. Future research should test whether this approach improves cross-context comparability and policy interpretability.

Reference

Martinez-Soto, A., Sanhueza-Catalán, D., Castro-Coliqueo, K., Macaya-Vitali, P., Zipf, A., Araya, P., Felmer-Plominsky, G., & Saldias-Lagos, Y. (2027). The structural fragmentation of energy poverty metrics limits global comparability and policy targeting. Energy for Sustainable Development, 96, Article 102157. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.esd.2026.102157